High Court awards Aamanya AG over USD 3 million after Ballinger wrongly cancelled FX forward contracts without paying fair market value
In a judgment handed down on 11 November 2026, Mr Justice Stanley in the Commercial Court, part of the Business and Property Courts found in favour of Aamanya AG against Ballinger & Co Ltd in a dispute over the termination of 25 foreign exchange (FX) forward contracts. The court held that Ballinger was entitled to cancel the trades in March 2022, having determined they had become derivative products outside the category it was authorised to offer under the parties' umbrella FX Agreement. However, the court also found that when Ballinger exercised that termination right, it was obliged to pay Aamanya the fair current market value of those contracts at the point of termination, rather than simply cancelling them for nothing. That payment obligation amounts to just over USD 3 million. On Ballinger's counterclaim, the court found that Aamanya had not deceived Ballinger about the nature of the trades, and that Ballinger had in any event failed to establish any recoverable loss. The case, cited as [2026] EWHC 2905 (Comm), turned on how to construe the termination provision in the FX Agreement and whether, once invoked, it carried an obligation to compensate at market value. O'Melveny and Myers acted for Aamanya, led by Oliver Assersohn KC and Rachel Carver. Brown Rudnick acted for Ballinger, led by Emmanuel Sheppard.
Sign up to read →